Sports Home Economics 101: Is Dick’s Trade in a Good Deal?

We’re reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.
Turn your old clubs into $
A great way to turn old clubs into $

If you happen to be a proud owner of an ancient set of golf clubs and you can’t seem to get rid of the lot, Dick’s Sporting Goods may have a perfect solution for you. With their used golf club trade-in program, you’ll be able to pack up your old (but hopefully well-preserved) clubs, ship them over to their evaluation facilities, and then receive a check, the amount of which will be based on the results of the assessment.

In this article, we’ll go into detail on this practical transaction and acquaint you with some of the rules and regulations surrounding it. As you will see, not all golf clubs are eligible for these trade-ins, so getting to know how things work in this area before you actually ship your ware might be a good idea.

Before we delve any deeper into the intricacies of trading in your golf clubs, let’s see who the company we’re dealing with here is and what their trading policies are. Without further ado, here’s the deal.

Table of Contents

DICK’S Sporting Goods – A Major Retailer of High-Quality Sports Equipment

Founded in 1948, the DICK’S Sporting Goods story is a truly inspiring one. Working at an army surplus store, young Dick was a hard-working chap who would enjoy his fishing and the fact he was NOT being called stupid by the shop owner. That all, however, was about to change. Following an ambitious proposal Dick wrote on the topic of expanding the business to cover fishing tackle, the shop owner dismissed it as useless and called the author a dumb kid.

That was the insult our plucky Dick couldn’t possibly live with, so he quit the job and related the story to his grandmother whom he loved dearly. Upon hearing the sad narrative, the grandma took forth her cookie jar and produced $300 to help her grandson open up his own tackle store. Thanks to Dick’s relentless entrepreneurial spirit, the business grew immensely in just 10 years, and has now become one of the leading sports equipment retailers in the US.

DICK’S Sporting Goods Golf Club Trade-In Policy

If you’re wondering about how the folks at DICK’S came up with the criteria for accepting or not accepting various golf clubs, there’s a rather simple explanation. DICK’S Sporting Goods Golf Club Trade-In Policy is based on the Value Guide – the national standard for golf club values used by many trade-in organizations dealing with golf clubs or other equipment. In the section below, we’ll describe the necessary requirements your clubs would need to meet in order to be accepted for a trade-in at DICK’S.

All things considered, trading in your old golf clubs can be a great way of decluttering your garage as well as earning some money. While the evaluating criteria can get pretty tough at times, as long as you didn’t slam your clubs against concrete or hurl them at some other hard surface, chances are it will pass the assessment with flying colors.
Dick's Sporting Goods Golf Club Trade-in

Requirements for Getting Your Clubs Accepted

Turns out, there are pretty rigorous standards when it comes to trading in your golf clubs. You can’t just assemble a bunch of golf club-looking objects, chuck them into a box and expect a decent evaluation score. Instead, other than requiring your clubs to be in a good condition, the folks at DICK’S will also want to see a certain number of them bundled together. Here are the rules in more detail.

The Clubs Must be Your Property

This one may sound like a no-brainer, but it’d still be worth pointing out that you can’t just sell someone else’ clubs just because they haven’t used them in a while or otherwise without their permission. Only the clubs that are your property are eligible for evaluation.

The Clubs Must be Authentic

If you’re not sure your clubs are authentic or cheap knockoffs, it may be a good idea to take them to a local golf club where someone who knows their golf can clear that up for you. Counterfeit clubs, no matter how well-preserved, won’t be considered for a trade-in.

The Clubs Must Not be Damaged

Although the evaluation-performing people at DICK’S won’t require the clubs to be 100% damage-free and as good as new, if they’re too damaged, especially in a way that would affect the playing performance, their value may drop significantly or they won’t be taken into consideration at all.

The Clubs Must Not be Rusty

When iron, wedge, and putter clubs are in question, one of the worst maladies that the passage of time tends to bring about would be rust. If your clubs happen to be rusty, make sure to clean the rust off before sending them in for evaluation. Beware, though; if you’re not sure as to how to proceed with this, you can easily damage the clubs. At the end of the day, remember that you can always consult an expert in restoration of sports equipment or a similar prominent artisan who knows about the art of NOT destroying valuable metal objects while removing the rust off of them.

Single Irons Won’t be Accepted

DICK’S Sporting Goods golf club trade-in rules state that only a set of clubs can be accepted for evaluation. A single club, no matter how well-preserved, will not be taken into consideration. Also, one of the metrics of the evaluation is the number of clubs in a set. The more there are, the better overall impression they will leave (8 sticks – the best option; 4 sticks or less – no deal).

Golf Club Accessories Should be Included Whenever Possible

When it comes to golf club accessories such as head covers, torque wrenches or other tools you might have acquired with the original set, it would be great if you could include them in the package you ship it off, as it will surely increase its value. Well-preserved club sets will probably be considered either way, so don’t worry if you don’t have the secondary equipment with you anymore.


This program is for you if you’re looking to upgrade your golf clubs. Whether its a beginner golf clubs or senior golf clubs, you don’t have to worry about keeping up with the new design and technology. With the Dicks Golf Trade Golf Trade Program, you can now upgrade your existing clubs and save money on your new golf clubs. As you continue to play with your game, you’ll be familiar with what kind of player you are on the course. You will soon know the features and golf clubs that suites better for a player like you. You can start making some changes to level up your game with Dick’s Sporting Goods Golf Club Trade-in Program.

Denny Putsh
Denny Putsh

With over 25 years experience in the world of golf, I've dedicated a significant portion of my life to appreciating this sport. From my early days swinging a club at 12 years old to now, my passion has only grown. While I avidly follow the PGA Tour, what truly captivates me is the evolution of golf equipment and technology. Over the years, I've familiarized myself with the latest gadgets, training aids, and golf accessories that enhance the golfing experience. My mission is to share this knowledge and enthusiasm with fellow golf aficionados, ensuring they have access to the best insights and recommendations. Whether you're a beginner or a seasoned pro, I'm here to guide you through the dynamic world of golf innovation.

Modern Golf Apparel